About This Blog

This blog is about recurrent problems with the Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority's public transit system. My particular crusade involves flagship line 910 (the "Silver Line") and its persistent, institutional unreliability after 9 PM.


I have been dealing directly and in good faith with Metro for some time now on this issue, but that private dialog has not resulted in any improvement in service. I started this blog in an attempt to provide another more public source of motivation for Metro to address their systemic failures.


Below I have posted my entire email exchange with Metro on this subject, and I will continue to update as the saga continues. The correspondence begins in November of 2011 only because that is when I discovered how to contact customer service. The problems with the silver line (and its transitway predecessors) started well before then. This email chain is unedited, except that I redacted my own name and contact info, and I removed redundant quotes of previous messages. Names and email addresses of Metro personnel have not been removed. I encourage you to contact them with your own thoughts. Also, feel free to leave comments here. I will probably delete anything vacuous or off topic, but if you have other complaints that aren't getting any traction, or if you have any suggestions that might improve service, please let me know.


For new visitors, the best way to read this blog is chronologically from bottom to top. The earliest entry is dated 2011-11-30. Since I can't seem to force all the posts onto one page, you'll have to start by clicking "2011" in the "Blog Archive" just below, or scroll all the way down and click "Older Posts."


Enjoy...

2012-06-29

From: fixmetro
Subject: Re: silver line MIA
Date: June 29, 2012 11:59:19 PDT
To: HorneT@metro.net
Cc: BoardSecretary@metro.net, borja.leon@lacity.org, AlejandroF@metro.net

Tom, thank you for the information. I hope you are posting signs at the other transitway stops that will no longer have service after 9. And there is a scheduled harbor freeway station silver line stop at 9:03, so I take it that that run will arrive on the street level. I hope the drivers will be aware of this and follow this new procedure starting with that run. 

This does not explain the missing 10 o'clock buses. I did receive an email from a Robert Holland and I do plan to call him when I have time... probably monday. 
From: HorneT@metro.net
Subject: FW: silver line MIA
Date: June 29, 2012 11:21:36 PDT
To: fixmetro
Cc: BoardSecretary@metro.net, borja.leon@lacity.org, AlejandroF@metro.net

Dear Mr. FixMetro:
On behalf of Metro please accept our apology for any hardship associated with the Silver Line problems you experienced.


A Metro Supervisor assigned to the investigation advises that an on site check revealed that Cal Trans is closing the Harbor Transit way at app. 9:20pm, instead of at 10pm as agreed and as noted in detour notice number 11-0082 (6th Revision).  Accordingly, buses were detouring early via Figueroa and leaving passengers waiting upstairs on the transit way.  A Metro representative was there last night to make one of the buses get on the transit way at the Green line station, where the operator was able to pick-up the patrons at the Harbor Station. She is posting the revised notices as we speak, informing patrons to begin waiting for buses down on Figueroa beginning at 9pm, instead of 10pm.  In addition to these efforts the Bus Operations controller will put our a verbal message reminding operators to use the detour route beginning at 9:00 PM.  We will continue to monitor the location to ensure scheduled on-time performance.  Please let me know if you experience any Silver Line problem.

Tom Horne
Manager
Customer Relations
213.922.7015

2012-06-27


From: Hollandr@metro.net

Subject: COMPLAINT RESPONSE
Date: June 27, 2012 14:08:08 PDT
To: fixmetro

Mr. FixMetro-  Please call me in response to you complaint of operations on the Silver Line.  Thank you.

Bob Holland
Service Operations Superintendent
213-922-4437

From: HorneT@metro.net
Subject: RE: silver line MIA
Date: June 27, 2012 08:53:46 PDT
To: fixmetro
Cc: CustomerRelations@metro.net, BoardSecretary@metro.net, borja.leon@lacity.org, SOTOPA@metro.net, ALARCONR@METRO.NET, AlejandroF@metro.net

Dear Mr. FixMetro
I and our senior staff read your very informative and detailed email with interest and concern.  Please be assured that you will be contacted by a senior official to discuss the issues you raise.  Again, our apology for the hardship you describe due to Silver Line service failures.   

Tom Horne
Manager,Customer Relations
213.922.7015
From: fixmetro
Subject: Re: silver line MIA
Date: June 27, 2012 01:44:49 PDT
To: HorneT@metro.net
Cc: CustomerRelations@metro.net, BoardSecretary@metro.net, borja.leon@lacity.org, SOTOPA@metro.net, ALARCONR@METRO.NET, AlejandroF@metro.net

Tom. Please don't read this email now. For full effect, please stay up until 1 am and read it then.

In answer to the first part of your email, NO. No one has contacted me. You need to GIVE ME the name and number of the uber-manager in charge of the silver line manager.

I understand that part of the function of a customer service department is to insulate others in the company from irate customers. You have done your job admirably. Let me know if you'd like me to write a positive letter to your line management. But the system has broken down here. If you want to serve the customer, give me the internal contact info I seek.

I would guess that metro customer service only hears from a very small percentage of the customers that metro so callously leaves in the lurch, and I would imagine that a majority of those you do hear from have nothing but vitriol for you. I think I have been extremely patient up until now, but this may be the last polite message you get from me, as the respectful approach clearly is not working.

Something is SERIOUSLY, SERIOUSLY wrong with the management of the silver line. I take other buses all the time. Sure, buses are often late, drivers are occasionally rude, but I have never had any trouble worth contacting customer service over on any of my thousands of other bus rides. The silver line is just in a class by itself.

Never mind the fact that inbound silver line buses are basically always standing room only in the morning... Never mind the fact that silver line drivers don't know metro's folding bike policies... These are indicators of poor management, but maybe can be chalked up to budget problems or a bad day or whatever. But when customers have to rearrange their schedules or routes specifically to avoid a particular line due to chronic truancy, then there is an undeniable reliability problem.

I have been leaving work earlier just to avoid the late-night silver line crap shoot. The last leg of my journey is a once-per-hour bus (at night), so when the silver line does not show up, it costs me an hour. That's on top of what is already a 2 hour + commute.

Before tonight, the last time I tried to take a late silver line bus was the last time I wrote to you to say that the bus never came. Tonight, the VERY NEXT TIME I've tried to take the silver line after 9 pm, it did not show up AGAIN. I was on Figueroa outside harbor freeway station waiting for the 10 pm silver line until 10:30. No bus. This is the 2nd stop, so it's hard to believe the bus could be more than a half hour late, and nextbus indicated that the 10 o'clock bus did not exist. I couldn't wait any longer because I cannot risk missing the last gold line to Pasadena. So I took the always efficient and enjoyable green-blue-red route to union station. I should find a way to work the expo line in there.

I have reported this habitual unreliability time and again, but as far as I can tell, nothing has improved. We can (and should) blame the drivers, but when a problem (that has been reported repeatedly) is this pervasive for this long, one cannot lay all the responsibility on skulking grunts. I haven't seen a metro org chart, but I'm guessing there is one obvious individual on whom the responsibility should fall. I want to talk to that person's boss.

So while I am impressed you had the temerity to ask, the answer to your second question is NO, I have not experienced any improvement in service delivery.

I am still waiting for that name and number.

2012-06-25

From: HorneT@metro.net
Subject: RE: silver line MIA
Date: June 25, 2012 12:36:36 PDT
To: fixmetro

Dear Mr. FixMetro
A review of your file indicates that a senior manager was assigned to contact you regarding the Silver Line and this email is to confirm that that was done.  Secondly, have you experienced an improvement in service delivery?   

Tom Horne
Manager,Customer Relations
213.922.7015

2012-06-22

From: fixmetro
Subject: Re: silver line MIA
Date: June 22, 2012 12:51:19 PDT
To: HorneT@metro.net
Cc: CustomerRelations@metro.net, BoardSecretary@metro.net, borja.leon@lacity.org, SOTOPA@metro.net, ALARCONR@METRO.NET, AlejandroF@metro.net

Still waiting for that name and number.

2012-06-14

From: HorneT@metro.net
Subject: RE: silver line MIA
Date: June 14, 2012 10:08:53 PDT
To: fixmetro
Cc: CustomerRelations@metro.net, BoardSecretary@metro.net, borja.leon@lacity.org, SOTOPA@metro.net, ALARCONR@METRO.NET, AlejandroF@metro.net

Dear Mr. FixMetro
Your report was received by our executive staff and is being investigated. I will contact you again upon receipt of the results of that effort.  Please accept our apology for any hardship caused by Silver Line delays.  

Tom Horne
Manager,Customer Relations
213.922.7015

2012-06-13

From: fixmetro
Subject: Re: silver line MIA
Date: June 13, 2012 22:25:04 PDT
Cc: customerrelations@metro.net, HorneT@metro.net, BoardSecretary@metro.net, borja.leon@lacity.org, SOTOPA@metro.net, ALARCONR@METRO.NET

Once again, no 9:33 pm silver line. I was at harbor freeway station waiting for it from 9:14 until almost 10:00. Nextbus said it was coming, but the predicted time kept getting later and later until it finally disappeared. I was not the only one waiting. Hopefully you'll be hearing from the others as well. 

Please tell me the name and number of whoever is in charge of whoever is in charge of the silver line drivers and schedules. That's right --- not the manager, but that manager's manager. I will politely repeat this request until fulfilled. At least, I will try to be polite about it. Thank you. 

2012-05-31

From: CustomerRelations@metro.net
Subject: RE: silver line MIA
Date: May 31, 2012 11:11:40 PDT
To: fixmetro

Mr. FixMetro,

Thank you for contacting Metro Customer Relations. I do apologize for the inconvenience this incident has caused. Please know that the Silver Line management staff is in receipt of your complaint and both operators will be identified shortly. If you encounter any further issues with Metro services, please let me know.

Richard Saldivar
Metro Customer Relations
213.922.4455

2012-05-30

From: fixmetro
Subject: Re: silver line MIA
Date: May 30, 2012 22:30:26 PDT
To: customerrelations@metro.net
Cc: HorneT@metro.net, BoardSecretary@metro.net, borja.leon@lacity.org, SOTOPA@metro.net, ALARCONR@METRO.NET

The 9:33 pm silver line never showed last night at harbor freeway station and the 10:02 pm silver line did not show up tonight. At least not on the street level where it is SUPPOSED TO BE. It's time for another talk with the drivers. Or better yet, just replace them all and instill good habits in the new hires.

2012-03-13

From: fixmetro
Subject: RE: silver line MIA
Date: March 13, 2012 18:10:28 PDT
To: HorneT@metro.net

The problem here lies solely with metro --- the drivers and their managers --- NOT the patrons.

I already knew that "patrons are supposed to wait on figueroa". That's what I've been doing. The problem is that the drivers don't seem to know that BUSES ARE SUPPOSED TO STOP ON FIGUEROA. The policy is clear to any patron that can read. Please tell the service planning manager to train the drivers on the policy. They must be on figueroa after 10 pm. The transition time has nothing to do with when caltrans decides to put up the detours on any given night. It is 10 pm. Period. Very simple. Please let me know when this training has occurred. Thank you.
From: HorneT@metro.net
Subject: RE: silver line MIA
Date: March 13, 2012 15:32:58 PDT
To: fixmetro

Dear Mr. FixMetro
Our Service Planning Manager responds to your question with the following:

Patrons are supposed to wait on Figueroa and 117th St. stop.  This stop is located under the 105 Freeway.  It is a regular stop location for Line 81 as well.

Tom Horne
Manager, Customer Relations
(213) 922-7015

-----Original Message-----
From: Horne, Tom 
Sent: Monday, March 12, 2012 12:44 PM
To: Page, Scott
Subject: FW: silver line MIA

Scott
Where is the bus suppose to stop???

Tom Horne
Manager,Customer Relations
213.922.7015
-----Original Message-----
From: Customer Relations 
Sent: Friday, March 09, 2012 10:27 AM
To: Horne, Tom
Subject: FW: silver line MIA

FYI


Metro Customer Relations
Karen Kern
213-922-2345

[...]

2012-03-08

From: fixmetro
Subject: Re: silver line MIA
Date: March 8, 2012 02:08:01 PST
Cc: customerrelations@metro.net, HorneT@metro.net, BoardSecretary@metro.net, borja.leon@lacity.org, SOTOPA@metro.net, ALARCONR@METRO.NET

So in the end it cost me about an hour and a half. That's on top of what is normally over a two hour (one way) commute. 

You might say I'd have been better off just waiting another hour at harbor freeway station for the 11 pm silver line, but as we all know there's no predicting whether that would be on the freeway or on the street. If I guess wrong, I miss the last gold line. 

Out of curiosity, how many metro employees take metro to work? 

2012-03-07

From: fixmetro
Subject: Re: silver line MIA
Date: March 7, 2012 23:31:32 PST
To: customerrelations@metro.net
Cc: HorneT@metro.net, BoardSecretary@metro.net, borja.leon@lacity.org, SOTOPA@metro.net, ALARCONR@METRO.NET

I'm just going to keep sending emails. I guess it's therapeutic somehow. 

Just now, march 7, 2012, I waited for a silver line bus scheduled to stop at harbor freeway station at 10:02 pm. Foolishly, I was out on Figueroa (street level), which is where the bus is supposed to be after 10 pm. You can probably guess where this story is heading. I'll give you the benefit of the doubt that the bus probably did actually come, but it certainly was not on the street level. I wrote an email complaining about this very thing the very last time I tried to take the 10 o'clock silver line (feb 7). Not that I really thought anything would change, but I guess I held out some faint hope that some sort of management structure might be in place. I won't be so naive in the future. 

It's gotten to the point that I've started to just cut my losses and take the much longer green-blue-red route preemptively, rather than take the 50-50-at-best crap shoot that is the night time silver line. Right now I'm sitting at Washington blue line station because I and the other cattle got kicked off the northbound train we were on and now have to wait another 20 minutes for a train the rest of the way to 7th. I tell you this in case anyone at metro is capable of empathy. 

So anyway, throw me a bone here. Tell me what to do. I'm all ears. Should I wait for the 10 o'clock bus on the freeway level? Is someone there going to actually talk to the silver line drivers and tell them that when the signs say street level after 10 that paying customers might actually be gullible enough to wait on the street level after 10? Should I just drive? Should I start a blog and take every other public opportunity to discourage people with choices from considering metro a viable transportation option? I know a lot of voters. 

Update: I am now on my second blue line train. We are currently stopped at San Pedro station for "10 to 12 minutes." I commend the driver for communicating this, but he then went on to suggest that passengers feel free to get out and smoke a cigarette. Just thought you'd like to know your drivers are suggesting illegal activities. 

Anyway, please ask the night time silver line manager to give me a call (310-XXX-XXXX). We have a lot to discuss. I'll send you all another email when I get home with the final tally of how much time your incompetent silver line driver cost me. I'm sure you can't wait. 

2012-02-28

From: fixmetro
Subject: Re: silver line MIA
Date: February 28, 2012 22:05:37 PST
To: HorneT@metro.net
Cc: BoardSecretary@metro.net, borja.leon@lacity.org, SOTOPA@metro.net, ALARCONR@METRO.NET

I was about to write another complaint about a bus not coming, but I think I'll just resend the message below. The same exact thing just happened again. And the incident in the email below is NOT even the last time this occurred. 

Please tell me the address to submit my cab fare reimbursement. Take it out of your driver's paycheck. Or I'll take a free EZ pass. Your choice. 

By the way, I'm still waiting to hear why there was no bus on November 30th. 

[forwarded email deleted]

2012-02-14

From: CustomerRelations@metro.net
Subject: RE: Yet another silver line problem
Date: February 14, 2012 09:56:48 PST
To: fixmetro

Mr. FixMetro,

Thank you for contacting Metro Customer Relations. I do apologize for the continued difficulties you have experienced with the Silver Line. Please know that our Vehicle Operations Staff will be monitoring the area to ensure that signage is correct and that our operators are following procedure during the construction phase. If you experience any further issues, please let me know.

Richard Saldivar
Metro Customer Relations
213.922.4455

2012-02-07

From: fixmetro
Subject: Yet another silver line problem
Date: February 7, 2012 22:45:44 PST
To: customerrelations@metro.net

I don't know why I keep sending complaints into the void... I guess it's cathartic. Anyway, here's another complaint for you to ignore. 

Tonight, 2/7/12, the northbound silver line scheduled to arrive at harbor fwy station at 10:02 pm apparently arrived on the freeway level. I only know this because someone who got off it happened to see me waiting on the street level (where I am SUPPOSED TO BE after 10, due to the nightly harbor transitway closure, right?). It's a good thing for me that your customers occasionally show concern for other customers, because time after time, your drivers show nothing but disregard for us. 

Please instruct your harbor transitway drivers that if the signs say to wait for the bus on the street level after 10, then they need to be on the street level after 10. This is not optional. People get ON buses, not just OFF. Thank you. 

2011-12-09

From: HorneT@metro.net
Subject: RE: silver line MIA
Date: December 9, 2011 15:33:54 PST
To: fixmetro
Cc: BoardSecretary@metro.net, borja.leon@lacity.org, SOTOPA@metro.net, ALARCONR@METRO.NET

Dear Mr. FixMetro:

Please accept our deepest apology for the hardship you experienced caused by the non-arrival of the Silver Line bus on Nov 30th.  Your report has been entered in the database from which copies are transmitted to management for investigation and corrective measures.  After I have received to cause of this delay I will contact you again.  Again my apology and if you have any service related problem please let me know. 

Tom Horne
Manager,Customer Relations
213.922.7015

2011-12-01

From: HorneT@metro.net
Subject: RE: silver line MIA
Date: December 1, 2011 16:25:55 PST
To: fixmetro
Cc: BoardSecretary@metro.net, borja.leon@lacity.org, ALARCONR@METRO.NET, SOTOPA@metro.net

Dear Mr. FixMetro
Please accept our apology for the service failure reported below.  We are already working to determine the cause and will make every effort to prevent a repeat of this incident.  Please know, we value your patronage. 

Tom Horne
Manager,Customer Relations
213.922.7015

-----Original Message-----
From: BoardSecretary 
Sent: Thursday, December 01, 2011 9:16 AM
To: Customer Relations; Horne, Tom
Subject: FW: silver line MIA

[...]

2011-11-30

From: fixmetro
Subject: silver line MIA
Date: November 30, 2011 22:50:38 PST
To: customerrelations@metro.net
Cc: boardsecretary@metro.net

The northbound silver line bus that is supposed to stop at harbor freeway station at 9:33 pm never came (nov 30, 2011). I was there from about 9:14 to about 9:50, at which point I checked nextbus and it said the next northbound bus was 20 minutes out. I gave up and went green-blue-red to union station instead. This is not the first time this has happened. Metro has basically eliminated every other freeway bus that connects union station to the green line. If your sole remaining line is unreliable, it sends the message that you don't care about your customers. 

If your drivers can't be bothered to actually make their runs or if your managers can't assure that they do, I'm sure there are plenty of qualified unemployed people out there who could happily switch places and do a better job. 

I take metro by choice. I could drive to and from work in about 1/4 of the time it takes me on metro, and snafus like this make that ratio even worse. Correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe part of your mission is to reduce the number of single-occupant vehicles on the road (ie, to attract and retain customers like me). Treating your customers as if they are stuck with you and have no other choices will pretty much guarantee that your only remaining customers are stuck with you because they have no other choices. 

Anyway, I'll be holding my breath, waiting to hear back from you about why there was no bus tonight and about how you are going to ensure that this doesn't happen again.